
When people look back at The Monkees, they often remember the television show first: the bright colors, the comedy, the quick edits, the four personalities who seemed to live inside a permanent burst of youthful chaos. Yet for Davy Jones, the reason the group endured for decades was never just the television series. It was the music, and more specifically, the extraordinary quality of the songs that somehow kept arriving at exactly the right moment.
Years later, Davy explained why The Monkees had access to so much remarkable material. In the mid-1960s, the music business was changing quickly. After The Beatles helped make it fashionable for bands to write their own songs, more and more groups began doing exactly that. The shift was exciting for artists, but it created a strange problem for professional songwriters who had spent years supplying material to singers and groups. Suddenly, some of the best writers in America had fewer places to send their songs.
The Monkees arrived at exactly the right time.
Davy remembered that the group had access to writers such as Neil Diamond, Carole King, Gerry Goffin, Tommy Boyce, Bobby Hart, Harry Nilsson, Neil Sedaka, Leiber and Stoller, along with others who were already respected or were about to become major names. Looking back, Davy said that because so many contemporary bands were writing their own material, The Monkees effectively received the “cream of the crop.”
That observation explains a great deal about why so many Monkees songs still sound familiar more than half a century later.
The group was created for television, and that origin brought criticism almost immediately. For years, detractors dismissed them as manufactured because outside writers and session musicians were heavily involved in the early recordings. Yet the same system that attracted criticism also gave The Monkees access to an astonishing pool of songwriting talent. Even after the members fought for and gained greater musical control, outside writers continued contributing some of their most memorable material.
Few examples illustrate that better than Neil Diamond’s “I’m a Believer.”
Diamond later explained that he had not originally written the song specifically for The Monkees. He had written it for himself and included it among his early material, but the people working with The Monkees heard what Diamond was doing and asked whether he had songs they could use. Diamond remembered sending material over and essentially telling them to take their pick.
They chose wisely.
With Micky Dolenz singing lead, “I’m a Believer” became one of the defining records of the Monkees phenomenon. The song reached No. 1 in the United States and became one of the group’s best-known recordings, helping turn a television project into a genuine pop-music force. Decades later, Diamond himself described the Monkees version as one of the biggest successes associated with his songwriting career.
The remarkable part is that “I’m a Believer” was not an isolated gift from Diamond.
He also wrote “A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You” and “Look Out (Here Comes Tomorrow)” for material that became part of the Monkees catalogue, while a vintage Davy Jones vocal on another Diamond composition, “Love to Love,” was eventually completed and released decades later on the 2016 album Good Times!
Diamond was only one part of a much larger songwriting machine.
Carole King and Gerry Goffin gave the group “Pleasant Valley Sunday.” Tommy Boyce and Bobby Hart helped shape the early Monkees sound and wrote songs including “Last Train to Clarksville.” John Stewart wrote “Daydream Believer,” the record that became especially associated with Davy’s voice. The names behind the songs read today like a list of some of the strongest writers in American pop music.
Davy understood the irony.
The Monkees were criticized because they did not always write the songs themselves, yet that same criticism overlooked the quality of the material they were being handed. In Davy’s view, the group benefited from a rare moment in the industry when brilliant professional songwriters needed artists willing to record their work, while The Monkees needed a constant supply of strong songs for records, television and touring.
The arrangement happened to benefit everyone.
The writers gained enormous exposure. The Monkees gained songs capable of surviving long after the television series ended. Fans gained records that still sound instantly recognizable decades later.
Micky Dolenz has made a similar point in more recent years, saying that the group had access to some of the best songwriters of their generation and that everything ultimately begins with a great song. In his view, if the songwriting is strong enough, the music has a chance to survive almost anything, including changing fashions and decades of criticism.
Davy Jones died in 2012, but his explanation still helps make sense of the Monkees legacy.
They happened to appear at a moment when television, pop culture and professional songwriting collided in an unusually productive way. The group may have been assembled for a television show, but the songs they received were not disposable television music. Many were written by people whose work would eventually become part of the foundation of modern pop.
And among them was one Neil Diamond song that still needs only a few seconds before generations of listeners recognize it.
The Monkees may have been created for television, but “I’m a Believer” helped prove that the music could outlive the show. Davy Jones understood why: when some of the greatest songwriters of the era were offering you their best work, sometimes all you had to do was recognize the song that could last forever.