NEIL DIAMOND HATED THIS SONG — But It Became One of His Biggest Hits!

By 1969, Neil Diamond desperately needed a hit.

He had already enjoyed success as a songwriter and recording artist, but after changing record labels, the momentum that had carried his early career began to slow. Neil later admitted that the period was frightening because he genuinely wondered whether his career might already be slipping away. He needed a song that could put him back at the center of popular music, and the answer arrived in a way he never could have predicted.

That song was “Sweet Caroline.”

Neil was in Memphis preparing for a recording session when he realized he only had two songs ready, even though a typical three-hour session was expected to produce three recordings. The night before entering the studio, he sat down in a motel and wrote another song remarkably quickly. Years later, he remembered it as one of the fastest songs he had ever written.

The next day, he recorded it.

Yet there was one problem.

According to Tommy Cogbill, the respected Memphis bassist who played on the session, Neil did not particularly like the song at first. Cogbill later recalled that Diamond was not enthusiastic about it and did not even want “Sweet Caroline” released as a single.

That hesitation is remarkable when viewed from the present.

Today, “Sweet Caroline” is almost impossible to separate from Neil Diamond’s name. Crowds sing along before he even reaches the chorus, sports stadiums around the world have adopted it as an anthem, and the familiar audience response has become part of the song itself.

None of that was obvious in 1969.

At the time, Neil was simply hoping that one of his new recordings might reconnect him with radio listeners after a difficult period. When “Sweet Caroline” was released, it became exactly the breakthrough he needed.

The song climbed to No. 4 on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming Neil’s biggest hit to that point and helping launch another powerful run of successful singles. Songs such as “Holly Holy,” “Cracklin’ Rosie” and “Song Sung Blue” soon followed, establishing Diamond as one of the defining singer-songwriters of the 1970s.

Even Neil later acknowledged just how enormous the song had become.

In a 2005 interview, he described “Sweet Caroline” as one of his biggest songs, possibly the biggest, and marveled at the fact that it had been written with so little struggle compared with songs that required months of work. He believed part of its enduring appeal came from something very simple: it was fun, easy to sing and invited everyone in the room to become part of it.

That communal quality eventually transformed the song beyond anything Neil could have imagined.

It became closely associated with the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park, spread to other sporting events, bars and celebrations, and turned into one of those rare recordings that people do not merely listen to; they participate in it.

The irony is hard to miss.

A song Neil Diamond reportedly did not want released became the song audiences expected to hear everywhere he went.

A track written quickly because he needed one more song for a recording session became one of the most permanent pieces of his legacy.

And a career that Neil feared might be losing momentum suddenly found new life.

Perhaps that is why the story of “Sweet Caroline” remains so fascinating.

Artists do not always recognize their biggest moments while they are creating them. Sometimes the song they struggle over for months disappears quietly, while the song they almost dismiss becomes the one the world refuses to forget.

Neil Diamond may not have believed in “Sweet Caroline” at first, but millions of listeners did. More than half a century later, the song he reportedly did not want released is still being sung by entire stadiums — proof that sometimes an artist’s greatest hit is the one even they never saw coming.

Video