Daniel O’Donnell with Mary Duff – It Doesn’t Matter Anymore

About the Song

A classic farewell, two heartfelt voices, and a duet that brings tender closure to love’s goodbye.

When Daniel O’Donnell and longtime musical partner Mary Duff joined forces on “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore,” they weren’t simply reviving an old song—they were breathing fresh warmth into a timeless ballad of lost love. Originally written by Paul Anka and made famous by Buddy Holly in 1959, just before his tragic passing, the song has long held a bittersweet place in the history of pop music. But in the hands—and harmonies—of Daniel and Mary, it becomes something softer, more reflective, and deeply resonant.

Both beloved for their smooth, easy-listening styles and deep connection with fans, Daniel O’Donnell and Mary Duff bring a natural chemistry to this duet. Their voices blend seamlessly: his calm, familiar tone pairing beautifully with her clear, emotive delivery. The result is a version of “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore” that feels less like heartbreak and more like acceptance—a gentle parting between two people who have come to terms with what was, and what can no longer be.

The arrangement stays true to the spirit of the original, but with an added elegance. The pace is unhurried, the instrumentation simple and graceful—acoustic guitar, soft strings, and just a hint of country sway. This is not a song that tries to stir up drama. Instead, it leans into a shared understanding, one that many listeners—especially older generations—will recognize in their own life stories.

What gives this rendition its quiet power is the emotional maturity both singers bring. There’s no bitterness, no blame—just a sense of two hearts gently letting go. It’s the kind of performance that makes you pause, perhaps even reflect on your own past, but without sadness. Just peace.

In the rich tradition of timeless duets, Daniel O’Donnell with Mary Duff remind us that even songs of parting can be beautiful. “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore” becomes, in their voices, a tender reminder that every ending carries the grace of closure—and that some songs, like some friendships, only grow more meaningful with time.

Video